Arguments¶
Shown while Transforming Mythic Europe is in play. An argument is a position someone means to win at a coming meeting, argued beforehand in writing. A polemic sets it out, diatribes attack it, and apologia defend it (Transforming Mythic Europe pp. 27-35). Choose an argument to see its total and its texts, and choose a text to read it in the panel below.
The arguments¶
Each argument with its reach, its proponent, its Argument Total and the debate bonus it buys ("−7: −3"). It says "not out" while its polemic isn't circulated.
What an argument records:
- Argument: the position, in a line.
- Its ideal: what its texts' Reputations name. That's Supporter of (ideal) for a polemic or apologia, and Opposed to (ideal) for a diatribe (pp. 31, 33, 35). Blank means the argument itself.
- It concerns: its reach on the Prevailing Wisdom Table (p. 29):
- a magus 3, or their Reputation if higher (His Reputation)
- a covenant 6
- a Tribunal 9
- a House 12
- the Order 15
- Proponent: who argues it.
- Written on: any knowledge Ability (p. 28). The book's suggestions come first: Code of Hermes, Order of Hermes Lore, and Area Lore with the troupe's agreement. Then come the other Academic and Arcane Abilities and the Lores.
- Goes to: the case or motion on the Docket where it's debated.
- It backs: the case or motion (its prosecutor or proposer), or the defence against it. A case or motion hears one argument for each side, and a second is refused. Adding two arguments' bonuses together would be a house rule, so answer the first with a diatribe or apologia instead.
- Last debate (editing): not yet debated, won, or lost. Holding the debate sets it.
The chosen argument¶
It shows the argument's reach and Prevailing Wisdom, its proponent, and its Argument Total worked out (pp. 31, 33). The total is the polemic's Quality − the Prevailing Wisdom, + each circulated apologia's Quality, − each circulated diatribe's, whoever wrote it. There's one total per argument. It also shows what the argument does in debate, what the next text still circulating would make it, and where it's debated.
At the hearing the total is spent as experience on the Art table (DE p. 49). 1 buys +1, 3 buys +2, 6 buys +3 and 10 buys +4. A negative total buys a penalty the same way. The bonus goes on every Attack and Defense roll of the side the argument backs, on top of Houses of Hermes: Societates's testimony and the rest. Won, the bonus carries to later Tribunals. Lost, at that Tribunal or a later one, it's gone (p. 35). Choosing not to debate it keeps the total for the next meeting.
Texts¶
The chosen argument's polemic, diatribes and apologia. A text is a link to a book in the saga's library, not a copy. Its Quality and level are read from the book, so add the summa or tractatus to the library first. It may belong to no one. A tractatus counts as level 5 (p. 28).
What a text records:
- Kind: one polemic per argument, written first. Diatribes and apologia answer it.
- Book: a summa or tractatus on the argument's Ability.
- Author: blank takes the book's author. When the text is added, a diatribe's author gains Opposed to (ideal) 1, and an apologia's Supporter of (ideal) 1. It's gained "on writing or circulating" (pp. 33, 35). An author who has it already gains 5 experience toward it.
- Studied the work it answers: a diatribe or apologia is written only after a season studying the work it answers (pp. 31, 35). It can't be circulated until this is ticked.
- Circulated to: a Tribunal (6 copies), a House (9) or the Order (18).
- Circulated by: a sponsor who circulates it with their own Reputation (p. 29). Blank means its author.
- Seasons spent circulating, New works bound with it: each adds to the next Circulation roll (see Circulate a Text).
- Circulated, Out since: whether it's out, and when.
More's Circulate a Text rolls a season's circulation.