How to hold a Tribunal¶
The Rhine Tribunal meets in Summer 1228, with one charge on its docket and one motion. The charge is Fengheld v. Keep, since Fengheld says Keep took the vis of the Rhine ford. Here's that meeting, from the roll call to the Closing.
The rules are Ars Magica Definitive Edition, Chapter 2: The Order of Hermes, Tribunals. Houses of Hermes: True Lineages (House Guernicus, Tribunal Procedures) covers hearing a case, and Houses of Hermes: Societates (House Tytalus, The Fine Art of Debate, pp. 90-92) the debate. Hold Tribunal has every step in full.
Before the meeting¶
- Put the cases on the Docket. On the Tribunal's Docket, add each case with who brings it, who it's against, and its Evidence, one testimony a line. Add its prosecutor and defender if you know them. Notice of a case is due a season before the meeting.
- Name the officers. Set the Tribunal's Praeco and Presiding Quaesitor on its sheet. Neither votes at the meeting.
- Open the Meeting. Open the Tribunal's page and its Meeting chapter. Before the meeting opens, the Order of Business lists the steps it would hold, day by day, and the top says "Not yet opened".
Moving through the meeting¶
- Start holding it. Click Hold under the Order of Business.
- Read where you are. Each step is a form that starts by saying where you are ("Step 3 of 9") and what comes next. Then come Worked out for you, what the app does at this step, and What you enter changes.
- Save to go on. Saving a step holds it and opens the next straight away, so you can go from the roll call to the Closing in one sitting.
- Stop when you like. Cancel stops. The meeting is saved after every step and waits at the step in hand, and Hold later carries on from there.
At the top of the chapter, Now names the step in hand and Then the one after it.
To change a step already held, choose it in the Order of Business and hold it again. It's held anew, and saving it goes on to the step in hand.
The roll call¶
- Call the roll. The first step lists each covenant's magi with all present ticked. Saving it opens the meeting.
- Mark who came. Untick all present for Keep and tick only the magi who came, since Leandro stayed home. For a sketch covenant, say how many of its unnamed magi came.
- Count the proxies. Give the proxies each covenant carries (Fengheld carries one sigil) and whether the Presiding Quaesitor allows them.
The app works out the votes in the hall and checks the quorum (see Hold Tribunal). The top of the Meeting shows Present ("4 votes, 1 by proxy") and Quorum.
On the desktop a card announces the meeting as it opens. Close it, and the next step opens.
Opening and the days¶
- Set the place and the days. Say where the meeting is held and how many days it lasts (3). Each case and motion is given a day, spread over every day but the last, which is kept for the rulings and the Closing.
- Move a hearing, if you like. Change a case's day to move its hearing and vote.
Hearing a case¶
- Choose the speakers. Fengheld v. Keep comes on its day. Choose the Prosecutor and Defender from the drop-downs, which list the magi present, each with their covenant.
- Fill an empty side. Leandro is absent, so the defence starts as A Guernicus advocate, who defends an accused who didn't come. A charge no one else will prosecute can be brought by The Presiding Quaesitor.
- Rate a speaker with no scores. A speaker with no debate scores written down, such as the advocate or a sketch magus, gets debates as: Middling, Able or Formidable.
- Debate. Leave Levels lost blank and the debate is rolled, round by round. Or play the debate out at the table and enter both sides' levels lost. Either way, the side that loses fewer wins, and the difference is its Argument Strength.
- Or settle it in private. If both sides accept the Presiding Quaesitor's view at the private hearing, tick Settled in private instead. The case has no debate and no vote, and goes straight on to its ruling.
- Hear the motion. For the motion, the proposer speaks for it and The Tribunal against, since a motion is debated against the whole hall.
The book has a Quaesitor step in only for a high crime, and drops a low crime no one prosecutes (True Lineages p. 56). The app offers the Quaesitor for any charge. How a rolled debate goes is in Hold Tribunal.
Calling the vote¶
- Read the leanings. The vote follows its hearing. Each covenant is listed with its leaning and why, such as "the case is against it" or "Warm (+1) toward Fengheld, which brings it".
- Change a leaning if the story says otherwise. The tally under the form follows as you do.
- Break a tie. If the votes tie, choose how the Praeco casts.
Call the Vote in The Hall shows the covenants called one by one, their seats filling.
Rulings and their terms¶
- Choose how to rule. On the last day, each case is ruled on. A ruling can be Written out, which starts as "Carried, 3 to 1", or made from a ruling template. Choose Holds for a term for Fengheld v. Keep.
- Set the fine and the Code. Set any fine (3 pawns of Aquam, paid by Keep) and whether the ruling goes into the Peripheral Code, and save.
- Fill in the blanks. The template's blanks come next. Fill them in, and the sentence under the form shows the ruling as you go.
Keep holds the Rhine ford's vis for 7 years, until it is debated again.
The {years} blank sets a term, as a written-out ruling's term in years does. The templates are the saga's own (see Hold Tribunal).
Closing, and what comes back¶
- Check the treasury. The Treasury step shows the balance and the loans due.
- Close the meeting. Closing decides each case with a ruling, writes the Acta into the Tribunal's Diary and sets the next meeting. Each step held has already written its minutes there.
Closing carries out each ruling, the fine owed to the treasury among them. The book gives a third of the fine to the prosecutor (True Lineages p. 57), but the app records it as owed to the treasury.
The term comes back on its own. Ahead lists the season before it ends (Spring 1235) and the season it ends (Summer 1235). Advancing into Spring 1235 says the term ends next season. Advancing into Summer 1235 says it has ended and puts "Fengheld v. Keep (debated again)" on the Docket for the next meeting, with the old ruling in its charge.
See also: Hold Tribunal, Meeting, Docket