Skip to content

Disputatio

Disputatio, in the Deeds chapter under Scholarly with Art & Academe in play, stages a schoolmen's debate with another character. Choose these:

  • who they dispute with
  • whether they're the Opponent, who states first, or the Respondent
  • the Subject, one of Artes Liberales, Philosophiae, Theology or Civil and Canon Law. Each side uses its score in it.
  • the Kind
  • the number of the judge's Questions, usually 7, 9 or 12
  • any Ease Factor the judge sets for the statements, such as 6 among students, 9 for baccalaureates or 12 for a candidate's examination.

The line above Dispute shows each side's totals before the die:

  • Attack: Communication + the subject's Ability.
  • Defence: Perception + the Ability.
  • Weakening: Intelligence + how far the Attack beat the Defence.
  • Resistance: Presence + the highest Academic Reputation.

Each question is an exchange. The opponent states and the respondent replies, then the respondent states and the opponent replies. A statement that beats the reply costs the other side a symbolic Fatigue level for every 5 points, or part of 5, by which its Weakening beats their Resistance, with the usual penalties. Five lose the disputatio. Otherwise the side that lost fewer wins when the questions run out. Dispute rolls it all and shows each exchange, and Keep writes it in both characters' Diaries.

Afterwards each rolls Stamina + a stress die against the number of questions. A failure costs a real Long-Term Fatigue level, and a botch one more for each 0. Keep takes these off their Fatigue.

The winner of an epideictic or deliberative disputatio gains an experience point toward a Good Academic Reputation, or gives the loser one toward a Bad one, once a season at most. The Diary notes it for you to add. The winner of a forensic one proves the case.

Virtues and Flaws count:

  • Afflicted Tongue -2 and Incomprehensible -6 to Attack
  • Good Teacher +3 in a deliberative disputatio, and Inspirational +3 in an epideictic one
  • Short Attention Span -3 to Defence
  • Piercing Gaze +3 to Weakening
  • Strong-Willed +3 to Resistance
  • Aristotelian Training +1 to every total
  • Poor Disputer -3 to each roll
  • Clear Thinker eases the Fatigue penalties by one
  • Enfeebled -1 a question after the first.

Before a crowd takes 3 from each roll of a Gifted disputer, unless theirs is a Gentle Gift. Academic Concentration and Aristotelian Training count for Artes Liberales as logic and rhetoric (Art & Academe, Chapter Eight: Universities).