Skip to content

Hold Tribunal

A Tribunal's meeting, held a step at a time from the Tribunal's Meeting. Each step is a short form: you make the decisions and enter the rolls, and the app works out the rest.

Every form says which step it is ("Step 3 of 12"), what comes next, what the app works out for you and what each thing you enter changes. The details panel says the same when you choose a step.

Saving a step holds it and opens the next, so a meeting can run from roll call to Closing in one go. Cancel stops, and the meeting waits at the step in hand. It's saved after every step, so you can leave it, and holding it again resumes there. For a meeting walked through from start to finish, see How to hold a Tribunal.

The rules are Ars Magica Definitive Edition's (Chapter 2, Tribunals). A quorum is twelve magi in person from four covenants and a Quaesitor. The Praeco and the Presiding Quaesitor don't vote, and the Praeco breaks a tie.

How a case is heard follows Houses of Hermes: True Lineages (House Guernicus, Tribunal Procedures). The debate follows Houses of Hermes: Societates (House Tytalus, The Fine Arts of Debate).

The steps run in a fixed order:

  • The roll call and proxies.
  • Tick each covenant's magi present one by one, or all at once with all present. Give how many of a sketch covenant's unnamed magi came.
  • Give the proxies each carries, and whether the Presiding Quaesitor allows them or sets them aside.
  • Under Hibernia's customs, also say whether each covenant shows its cathach. One that doesn't has no votes.
  • The votes in the hall are worked out (the Praeco and the Presiding Quaesitor are present but don't vote), the quorum is checked, and the proxies are kept on the roster.
  • Only the magi ticked present can speak at a hearing. A proxy carries a vote, never a voice.
  • Saving it opens the meeting, and cancelling holds none.
  • Opening and the oaths: where it's held, how many days it lasts, and the day each case and motion is heard. A meeting lasts as many days as its Tribunal's customs give: Hibernia's seven (The Contested Isle p. 32), three elsewhere. Days on the Opening changes it.
  • The new magi and the sigils by proxy, under the Rhine's customs, the first business after the Opening (Guardians of the Forests pp. 24, 26-27).
  • Every magus of its covenants who passed their Gauntlet since the last meeting is introduced. Tick each, or name others not in the saga.
  • Then the rite confers a retired magus's sigil on each master and archmage made since, by the Mark of Approval or the Archmage's Challenge. Name whose sigil it is, typically their master's, if retired.
  • Each sigil adds a proxy to the magus's covenant's votes, at this meeting and the next. Holding the step again confers afresh, never twice.
  • The Hermetic Assembly, on the first day under the Theban customs, in two steps. The Theban Law Council and People's Court are the meeting's motions and cases, below.
  • The Assembly's decrees name the principal phyle governing the meeting. It's the next in turn (Ionian, Aegean, Kretan, Propontian), unless you choose another.
  • A decree of citizenship for each metoikos makes them a polites.
  • A decree of contrition for each polites with a shard takes one away. It asks the reparation: what the magus offers, and its vis in pawns of an Art. When the decree is accepted, those pawns leave the magus's own vis for the Tribunal's treasury, as many as they have (The Sundered Eagle p. 33). Holding the step again gives them back first, and the minutes name each reparation.
  • A decree of defamation against a polites, if upheld, gives the accused a shard. If rejected, it gives the one who brought it a shard.
  • The ostrakismos: the logothete reads every polites holding a shard, and the one on the most sherds, or no one, is ostracised. They become a metoikos, lose their tokens and shards, and may not return for seven years.
  • The Apprentice Presentation, under the Theban customs, between the Assembly's decrees and the ostrakismos. These are the Gifted children the Treasury Council found, interviewed for two days before the meeting.
  • Enter each child the troupe's magi interviewed, up to five, with their age. Give who delivered them to the Council, since a polites who did earns a token (The Sundered Eagle p. 28). Give the tokens each magus gave them, up to three magi.
  • Only a polites with no shard may give tokens, or any Bonisagus even with one, since the Code trumps local custom. No magus may give more tokens than they hold (p. 32).
  • A child given tokens by one magus is that magus's apprentice. One given tokens by several chooses, usually the one who gave the most. The app picks that one, the first entered on a tie, unless you choose another of them. A child given none may be claimed by any magus, even one with a shard (pp. 33-34).
  • Any Bonisagus may claim any child outright by the rights the Oath gives their House, whether or not they gave tokens, and whatever their shards. Name them under Claimed by, shown only when the Tribunal has a Bonisagus. The child's choice doesn't override them. By tradition the Bonisagus still gives a token or two. Enter them as their bid, and the child keeps them (p. 32).
  • The master's tokens leave the master and stay with the child, to spend once they're a magus. The others' go back to them.
  • Each child given becomes a Sketch character at their master's covenant, with the master as parens and the tokens they keep in their summary. Once given, holding the step again changes only its note.
  • Each case and motion, on its day, is a debate between the prosecutor and the defender. For a motion, it's one who speaks for it and one against.
  • Each is chosen from a drop-down of the magi present, shown with their covenant. The prosecution may instead be the Presiding Quaesitor, who prosecutes a high crime no one else will. The defence may be a Guernicus advocate, who defends an accused who didn't come. A motion's opponent may be the Tribunal itself, since a proposer debates the whole hall.
  • The case's own speakers are chosen to start with, or the magus it names, or a magus of the covenant it names. An accused who is absent is given the advocate.
  • A charge or appeal can instead be settled at the private hearing, when both sides accept the Presiding Quaesitor's ruling. Tick Settled in private. It then has no debate and no vote, and its ruling starts as "Settled at the private hearing".
  • Enter each side's debate Fatigue levels lost, or leave both blank and the debate is rolled round by round. That follows Houses of Hermes: Societates (The Fine Arts of Debate).
  • Each round, Communication + Folk Ken, Intrigue or Artes Liberales is rolled against Intelligence + Charm, Guile or Leadership. Artes Liberales counts as logic and rhetoric, for Academic Concentration and Aristotelian Training. Each debater uses what they're best at, by lot each round among Abilities of the same score, the app's stand-in for their choice of tactic (Houses of Hermes: Societates pp. 90-91).
  • A hit costs debate Fatigue only when Presence and the margin beat the defender's Resistance, their best positive Reputation + Confidence (+3 Strong Willed). So a weak speaker's hits on a well-known magus can cost nothing (p. 90).
  • A speaker with none of those scores written down, such as an advocate, the Tribunal or a sketch magus, debates at the skill you give. The rules give no figures for them, so these are the app's. Middling is an ordinary magus, Characteristics 0 and those Abilities 2. Able is Characteristics +1 and Abilities 4. Formidable is Characteristics +2, Abilities 6 and a Reputation of 3.
  • The case's Evidence is the prosecution's testimony, and the Defence testimony the defence's, each used once. A peer's is +3, an apprentice's or familiar's +2, any other +1, and +3 more if a Quaesitor examined it.
  • The side that lost fewer levels wins, and the difference is its Argument Strength. A motion that adds to the Code takes 1 off it, and one that alters it 3.
  • Heard by (a charge or appeal) is Debate, as above, or certamen. Certamen in its place binds the case however persuasive the loser. Say who won, and the case goes to its ruling with no vote.
  • With Certamen on one point of it, the Fatigue levels each side actually lost stand in for the debate's levels lost, and its winner doesn't win the vote by it (Houses of Hermes: Societates p. 92).
  • Certamen in its place is offered only for a personal charge one magus brings against another, when the charge names no violation of the Code. It can't over-rule a Tribunal, so an appeal against a ruling is debated. It can't require a violation of the Code or a magus to overlook one, so a charge naming a high or low crime is debated too (DE p. 230). The Heard by hint says why when it isn't offered.
  • Argues, for each side, is In good faith or Knowing it false. Knowing it false takes the speaker's Truthful Personality Trait off each of their Defence Totals, and a deceitful Trait gives nothing. A flawed, despised or preposterous thesis starts the debate 1, 2 or 3 levels down (The Power of Truth, p. 91).
  • A motion opposed by "The Tribunal" is debated by the whole hall. Each round a different magus present, the proposer aside, questions the proposer, at the skill you give the Tribunal if that magus has no scores written down. The levels lost are all the Tribunal's (p. 92).
  • Changes (a motion) is the Peripheral Code, or the Peripheral Code and recommended to the next Grand Tribunal, since a regional Tribunal can change only its own Code. Or it's heard at the Grand Tribunal, which costs the proposal 1 more Argument Strength on top of an Addition's 1 or an Alteration's 3 (p. 93).
  • The vote on each case.
  • Each covenant's leaning, which you can change, shows with why it leans that way under it. It brings the case, the case is against it, or it has an attitude toward a troupe covenant that's a party.
  • The debate wins votes. An Edge wins 10% of the undecided votes, up to a Landslide's 60%. A Triumphant Victory wins 10% to 30% of the other side's too.
  • The covenants are called one by one and the tally kept. What's left undecided abstains.
  • On a tie the Praeco casts the deciding vote: choose for or against. On a call for a Wizard's March a tie defeats it.
  • The Sacred Council, on the first day under Hibernia's customs. Tick each faction's ambassador confirmed for this meeting, from the Tribunal's Ambassadors, and write the disputes heard. Each confirmed ambassador votes as a magus does. They're called after the covenants, undecided unless named as a party, and you can change their leaning like a covenant's.
  • The Praeco's succession, on the first day under Normandy's customs. With no Praeco, the eldest magus of the Tribunal, by Year Born, is offered. Set them aside by choosing the next eldest. The one named becomes Praeco, and the minutes say who was passed over.
  • The Library of the Tribunal, under Normandy's customs (The Lion and the Lily pp. 22-23). The books the Tribunal owns in common are kept at Confluensis, read only by those who win them at the Tourney. Each goes out on a seven-year lease, back before the next meeting. At the Library step:
  • Tick each lease that's up as returned. One left unticked is noted as still held.
  • Record a book a magus of the Tribunal wrote and gave to the Library, which goes to Confluensis. Record too the giver's prize, a Library book worth no more Build Points than the gift. There's one lease for each book given, as many as there are to give.
  • Record each book won at the Tourney, with the covenant that won it, as many as the Library has free.
  • A team buys its books with the prize pawns its rank won at this year's Tourney. Record its points on the Tribunal's Tourney first. A book costs a pawn per 5 Build Points, a fraction counting as a pawn, and the step refuses a team's books costing more than its pawns.
  • At the Tourney each team takes one tropaeum or lump of vis and one book or item a round, in rank order, then picks again while pawns remain (The Lion and the Lily p. 33). The pawns it spends on tropaea and vis aren't counted here.
  • A leased book stays the Tribunal's, kept at Confluensis, and the lessee has seven years' exclusive access. Two prizes can't name one book. When two contributors want the same book, certamen settles it.
  • Residency, under Provence's customs (Faith & Flame p. 22).
  • A magus is a resident of the Provençal Tribunal who attended one of its last three meetings, or was granted residency by vote at their first, or registered on arriving. They register with the Redcaps and the Praeco, or their nearest neighbour.
  • One Gauntleted in the Tribunal is a resident until three meetings pass without them.
  • The meeting's roll of residents records the magi present, lets you grant residency to a newcomer present, and records a resident's departure, registered or not. Voting at another Tribunal without registering a departure breaks the Peripheral Code.
  • Until three meetings are recorded, every magus of the Tribunal is presumed a resident. A magus's sheet shows their residency and why.
  • The execution of sentences, on the last day under the Theban customs, before the outgoing magistrates are paid (The Sundered Eagle pp. 28, 35).
  • Each charge the People's Court heard takes its verdict from how its vote went. Carried is convicted, failed is exonerated, and settled or not voted is no verdict.
  • A conviction gives the guilty three shards for a High Crime or one for a Low Crime, beside its punishment. The magus who brought the case gets a token, or three if the guilty was Marched. A case the Court defeated gives its bringer a shard.
  • Choose the accused and the accuser from the Tribunal's magi. The step guesses them from the case's names.
  • A metoikos is given no tokens or shards. No March is held on Delos.
  • The conduct of archai, under the Theban customs, after the sentences (The Sundered Eagle p. 35).
  • Any polites may ask that the conduct of an arche, or of the polemarch, be examined, naming the fault and proposing a fine of one to seven shards. The archon counts as an arche, since the archon is elected from the archai. A fault may be a case poorly defended or prosecuted, a bribe, or indolence.
  • There may be up to three complaints. For each, give the magistrate, who brought it, the fault, the fine and how the votes went.
  • A complaint upheld with its fine gives the magistrate the shards. One rejected, or whose fine is voted down, gives none.
  • Failing to win or stop a conviction is no fault unless the neglect was willful.
  • The logothete isn't offered, since the book names only an arche or the polemarch. Holding the step again undoes the first holding first.
  • The common vis sources, under the Theban customs, before the outgoing magistrates' tokens (The Sundered Eagle pp. 28-29). These are the vis sources the Peripheral Code holds in common, gathered for the Tribunal by magi the Treasury Council names.
  • For each source, give its Art, its gatherer and the pawns brought into the coffers. The pawns go into the treasury as vis.
  • Each gatherer earns a token for the period, one for each source they gather. The book's "one per Tribunal period" could also mean one per magus however many they gather, so this is the app's reading. If your troupe reads it the other way, give back the extra by editing the gatherer's tokens.
  • A gatherer who forgot to harvest (tick Neglected) is given a shard and brings in nothing.
  • The sources and their gatherers are kept, so the next meeting's form starts with them.
  • The whole Tribunal gathers some 50 pawns a year, Creo and Vim the most, about half of it spent on the yearly Longevity Ritual (pp. 29-30).
  • The Council of Archai, on the last day under the Theban customs, in three steps.
  • The outgoing magistrates' tokens: each outgoing magistrate is paid in tokens, 2 for an arche, 3 for the archon and 5 for the polemarch. Untick one to pay nothing.
  • The sortition: four archai are drawn by lot from each phyle, the principal phyle first, from its politai who aren't archai now. Redcaps aren't drawn. The draw is kept, so holding the step again draws no one new. One magus drawn may be set aside for the next drawn from the same phyle.
  • A phyle with fewer than four politai leaves its other seats for the logothete to fill with Redcaps.
  • A drawn magus set aside because they refused to stand is given a shard (choose "Refused to stand"). One set aside for any other cause isn't (The Sundered Eagle p. 32).
  • The new archai are then placed on the boards. Those who've been archai before go first, each on a board they haven't sat on, by lot where they have a choice. Then the rest go by lot until each of the Judicial, Legislative and Conciliatory Boards has three.
  • The others form the Treasury Council. One is drawn tamias, four gather vis and Gifted children (one from each phyle where they can), and the rest are tutors.
  • A board no arche can fill is left to the logothete's Redcaps, and the minutes say how many seats.
  • Each arche's Duties say where they sit, and the Tamias office takes the one drawn. The Tribunal remembers who has sat on which board (pp. 27-28, 35). The new archai serve until the next meeting.
  • Archon and polemarch: the new archai elect the archon from among themselves, the eldest offered first, and the polemarch from every polites. The archon becomes the Tribunal's Praeco.
  • Rulings and fines: the ruling on each case, starting from how its vote went.
  • The ruling is written out, or made from a ruling template (see below).
  • Give any fine, in pawns of an Art or, with no Art, pounds of silver, and who pays it.
  • Say whether the ruling goes into the Peripheral Code. A motion's does unless you say otherwise.
  • Term is the years after which the matter comes back.
  • For a case between a troupe covenant and another, say how the other's attitude toward the troupe moves. A party that lost takes it ill, -1.
  • A case that may March the accused asks Marched. That's a conviction for a high crime when the prosecution called for a March and a simple majority carried it (a tie defeats it), or a Quaesitor's March the Tribunal ratified (Houses of Hermes: True Lineages pp. 58, 63).
  • A charge also asks how many times the convicted magus refused a lesser penalty. At three they're Marched whatever the crime (p. 59).
  • Closing the meeting writes the March on the outcast's Hermetic Background, with the year and the Tribunal that renounced them, when the case's Against names a character. They're safe until the Tribunal closes, then outside the Code (DE p. 18; p. 60).
  • A declaration of Wizard's War isn't heard unless its service is disputed. The hunt itself isn't worked out.
  • Treasury and vis: the treasury as it stands and the loans that fall due this year.
  • The next host, by lot, under Normandy's customs. A covenant of the Tribunal is drawn, and may be drawn again once, the second draw standing. It becomes the Tribunal's meeting place, and the minutes say where it meets next.
  • The tithe of Gifted children, under Hibernia's customs. The Coill Trí bring a Gifted child from each of their seven túatha, as the Tribunal records them, else unnamed.
  • Each túath offers three, made once and kept. The first is brought unless you choose another, which is a reroll.
  • Each child has a name, an age from 5 to 12, a Gift (ordinary, Gentle or Blatant), a sign or two of what they may become, and where they come from.
  • Now and then a child has no true Gift, which only this examination shows. They're turned away.
  • Then give them out By hand, choosing a magus of a represented covenant for each, or none. Or give them out By bidding. Each represented covenant with a magus who has no apprentice bids vis: a roll of a ten-sided die, 2 pawns for each such magus and a tenth of its vis. It bids more for a Gentle Gift and less for a Blatant, never more than it holds.
  • The highest bid wins the child for its first such magus. The price is taken from its Raw Vis Stores, the fullest first, each in its Diary.
  • The outcome shows under the form before you give them. Each child given becomes a Sketch character at their master's covenant, with their master as parens, and the minutes list where every child went. Once given, holding this step again changes only its note.
  • A magus has an apprentice when someone not yet a magus names them as parens.
  • The book says only that the Coill Trí owe seven Gifted children and that a child offered is sometimes turned away (The Contested Isle pp. 113-114). The three each túath offers, the odds of each Gift (14, 3 and 3 in twenty, one in twenty no true Gift) and the bidding are the app's own.
  • The Ceremony of Propitiation, under the Theban customs, before the closing.
  • The archon casts the ancient Ritual from its Casting Tablet at eight pawns of Creo or Vim, taken from the treasury. Then each covenant offers to its patron.
  • Enter the pawns each covenant offers and its patron's Might, which is remembered for next time. Each patron gains 25 xp less its Might, the Might cut by two for every pawn offered. So a Might 25 patron offered 10 pawns gains 20 xp.
  • The League Against Idolatry boycotts the rite (The Sundered Eagle p. 31). The pawns offered aren't yet taken from the covenants' own stores.
  • Closing: each case with a ruling is decided, and what its ruling says is written.
  • The fine is owed to the Tribunal's treasury.
  • The ruling goes into the Peripheral Code.
  • The attitude's move becomes a reason on the covenant's attitude.
  • A term's end goes on the case.
  • The Acta, the meeting's acts set out as a charter, goes into the Tribunal's Diary, and the next meeting is set for when the Tribunal next meets.

Ruling templates. A template's blanks are asked after the Rulings step, one form a case, with the finished sentence shown under it as you fill them. "{party} holds {what} for {years} years, until it is debated again" becomes "Keep holds the Rhine ford's vis for 7 years, until it is debated again". A {years} blank sets the term. A blank is any word in braces. The templates are the saga's own, kept in the saga's settings (the saga, Ruling templates), where you can add, change and remove them.

They include the Code's penalties (Houses of Hermes: True Lineages pp. 59-61):

  • Damages: a fine shared a third to the prosecutor and two thirds to the Tribunal's coffers.
  • Seasons of service.
  • Investing items.
  • Loss of an apprentice.
  • Banished.
  • Loss of a familiar.
  • Death of a familiar.
  • Cast out: the estate goes a quarter to the victim, a quarter to the prosecutor, a half to one who is both, and the rest to the heir (Houses of Hermes: True Lineages p. 59). A case's details show beside it the established convention that whoever slays the outcast takes the heir's half once the others are paid (p. 53).

Any step can be held again to change it. Saving it then goes on to the step in hand. Every step has a Note for anything said or decided in your own words.

Terms that come due. A ruling made for a term comes back. Ahead lists the season before its term ends and the season it ends. Advancing into the season before says it ends next season. Advancing into the season it ends says so, and puts the matter back on its Tribunal's docket as a new case for the next meeting, such as "Fengheld v. Keep (debated again)", with the old ruling in its charge. The case's details on the Docket show when its term ends.

The minutes. Each step held writes its minutes into the Tribunal's Diary. The entry is headed with its day ("¶ The First Day: The roll call and proxies"), with its numbers in the margin, such as the votes in the hall, a vote's tally or a fine, and its Note after its own words. Holding a step again rewrites its entry rather than adding another. The Acta, like any Diary entry, can be reworded by editing it. On the desktop, choose the Acta in the Diary and press Print to print it to a PDF.

Transylvania's meeting. Two steps come before the rulings.

The Praeco's purse (Against the Dark p. 19). The Tribunal gives the Praeco the projects they're to fund until the next meeting, and with them the levies they may raise.

  • Write the projects, then a levy on each oppidum, in pawns of an Art, or in pounds with the Art left blank.
  • The book has the legal covenants of the cives, socii and coloniae, and some of the foederati, owe the projects reasonable aid. They owe it by their status, not each magus for themselves. The hospites' covenant isn't named, so an oppidum of hospites can't be levied.
  • The app lays each levy on an oppidum, and its hint says which of the oppidum's magi belong to a covenant that owes aid. Each levy goes on the treasury, owed until it's marked paid.
  • The pawns from the large vis source set aside for the Praeco come into the treasury.
  • The Praeco collects the Redcaps' and Quaesitores' stipends and Redcaps deliver them, so they only go into the minutes.
  • The Praeco may redeem promissory notes, whose pawns leave the treasury, and issue a new one. What it borrows comes into the treasury now.

The Curantis and his Notary (p. 97). The Curantis keeps the zenodochia, the Tribunal's safehouses for travelling magi. They're appointed at every meeting for a term to the next, usually unopposed, and no one serves two terms running.

  • Say whether the outgoing Curantis built a new zenodochium in their term, as they're expected to.
  • Choose the new Curantis and the Notary the outgoing Curantis selected, often a Redcap or a magus fresh from their Gauntlet. Give the Curantis's salary, which leaves the treasury now.
  • Both then show as offices on the Five Covenants list. A colona may not be Curantis.

See also: How to hold a Tribunal, Tribunal sheet, Meeting tab